The number every author should read twice
This week a figure came out that stopped me mid-coffee.
A study of more than 2,000 books in Amazon's Religion & Spirituality category found that 63% of the titles published in the past year were likely written by AI. When the researchers looked only at Catholic books, the share was about the same (National Catholic Register).
Read that again. Not 6%. Not one in ten. Close to two out of every three new books in an entire category.
The same report cites another study: AI-generated fiction has already produced tens of millions of dollars in sales over the past three years. This is no longer an experiment at the edges of the store. It is a business model.
When your book gets a twin you never wrote
Volume is only half the problem. The other half is imitation.
Catholic Answers Press discovered that one of its real books, The Apostolate of Courtesy by Robert B. Greving, had spawned AI-generated copies on Amazon: identical titles, ornate covers and invented authors with names like “Caleb Truthwell.” The press complained. The complaint went through an automated system that replied there was no trademark or copyright violation. The copies are still for sale.
So what is Amazon doing? Something, but not what readers might assume:
It does not ban AI-generated books. It asks authors who self-publish to declare whether they used AI, but buyers never see that declaration.
It is slowing the flood. In September 2026, Amazon cut the number of titles an account can submit to KDP to two per week per format (ebook, paperback, hardcover), down from ten per week a year earlier (Forbes). Amazon has not said why.
A speed bump is not a wall. And a disclosure nobody sees doesn't help the reader decide.
From being found to being believed
When I published my first book, my biggest fear was silence. I thought the problem was visibility: how do I get a reader to find me among millions of titles?
That problem hasn't gone away. But a new one has quietly moved in front of it.
Today the indie author's challenge is not only being found. It is being believed. A reader who has bought one hollow, machine-written book becomes suspicious of the next unknown name on the screen. Fair or not, that suspicion now lands on all of us.
And here is the uncomfortable part: you cannot win this race on speed. A machine will always publish faster than you. If your strategy is “more books, sooner,” you are competing on the one field where you are guaranteed to lose.
What a machine can't fake is a story that holds up over time.
Five ways to prove you exist
None of these require a big budget. All of them require consistency, which is exactly what a content farm doesn't have.
Show up in more than one place, with the same face and name. A website you own, a profile on Goodreads, an active social account. A fake author lives only on a product page. You don't.
Answer your readers. Every reply to an email, a comment or a review is public proof that a person is behind the book. Machines publish; people respond.
Keep your voice recognizable. Your opinions, your examples, your way of telling a story. Readers who know your voice will spot an imitation before Amazon does.
Leave a trail with dates on it. Posts, articles, talks, even your mistakes and what you learned from them. A history that accumulates over months and years is very hard to fake overnight.
Be honest about how you use AI. If it helps you with research, editing or translation, say so. Transparency is becoming a competitive advantage, not a confession.
And if you find a copy of your own work, don't stop at the automated form. Document it, keep the links and the dates, and escalate to a human contact or an authors' association.
Your best defense
I don't think AI is the enemy of authors. I use it, and I'll keep using it. The problem isn't the tool. It's a book with nobody behind it, presented as if there were.
So your best defense isn't writing faster.
It's proving you exist.
Are you seeing this in your own category? Have you found a copy of your work, or a suspicious “author” next to yours? Write to me. I read every message.
Álvaro Silva
Website: alvarosilvaauthor.com
Blog: more articles
Amazon: author page
Instagram: @alvarosilvaauthor
Goodreads: alvarosilvaauthor

